Is Penmanship Being Written Off?

By: CBS Email
By: CBS Email

"Letter R! Letter R! R-r-r … Today, we're going to introduce how to make the letter R."

Remember this? If it's been a while since you felt the excitement (or the pain) of putting pen to paper, spend a few moments with Krista Walther's kindergarten class in Upper Arlington, Ohio.

"This is not something that you can leave out - you have to teach these fundamental letter formations, or else the kids are really going to struggle," she said.

"You can see so much meaning and passion in their penmanship. You know, even if it's, you know, all in capitals and a mix, it makes you smile."

Handwriting is still an essential skill for kids. But in the world beyond school - the one filled with computers and cell phones and you-name-it - we're losing our grip on penmanship.

It's not that we're not writing. We send 294 billion e-mails, and nearly five billion text messages EVERY DAY.

But for adults, the tactile, personal art of handwriting has pretty much been reduced to shopping lists and credit card signatures.

Tamara Plakins Thornton, a history professor at the State University of New York at Buffalo says that's an old story. "That goes back to the typewriter, actually. It doesn't go back to the computer. We haven't used handwriting the way we used to use handwriting for well over 100 years."

Thornton is the author of a cultural history of handwriting in America

She said handwriting was an issue even in the time of the pilgrims.

"First, you have to recognize that not everybody could write," Thornton said. "And then even more strangely, there were people who could read but not write. The two skills were taught separately and understood to have separate purposes."

In the 1700s and 1800sm, if your handwriting was good enough, you could actually make it a career.

"There were professional penmen - professional writing masters who would produce penmanship tour de forces as a kind of calling card: 'This is what I can do,'" she said.

Platt Rogers Spencer was the first American penman to create a national model for handwriting - and it was a fancy one.

"Spencerian was very fussy and time consuming. You had to get the shading just write," said Thornton. "So, it was slow."

We know Spencerian today as the script used in the Coca-Cola logo. But that's about all.

Because the arrival of the typewriter in the late 19th century presented enormous competition for handwriting, a new man took up the challenge: A.N. Palmer.

Thornton called him "the penmanship emperor of the 20th century."

Palmer said . . . speed it up.

Thornton said Palmer's creed was, "We have to have a modern 20th century script for modern 20th century business conditions - fast, efficient. That way we can keep up with the typewriter."

The Palmer method, like the Spencerian method, is big on physical discipline. It's big on drill work - regimentation that Palmer believed would do more than just create good handwriting, it could make model citizens.

"Penmanship could reform delinquents," explained Thornton. "Penmanship could assimilate immigrants. Penmanship could do just about everything except cure acne."

Moreover, handwriting was seen not just as the product of good habits, but of your character itself.

And that gave rise to graphology - handwriting analysis.

It was all the rage, particularly in the early 1900s. There were even graphology columns in magazines, to which readers could submit their handwriting to find out their true self.

One example read: "I can see great deal of narrow mindedness, some priggishness, considerable self satisfaction…"

And get this: before the 1920s, students weren't taught to write in print. They ONLY learned cursive.

So, Abraham Lincoln never printed? "He would not have printed," said Thornton.

And learning script took a lot of time.

"We recommended back then - and most teachers did - about 30 to 45 minutes of direct instructions for handwriting and handwriting practice," said Kathleen Wright, the national product manager for Zaner-Bloser, one of the largest handwriting instruction companies.

Wright says they've had to adapt to all the subjects crammed into a student's schedule.

"We realize that that's an unreasonable amount of time, so we've simplified it to about 15 minutes of direct instructions a day," she said.

Today, children start with print, then move on to a cursive, in lessons that have been whittled down over the years from 45 minutes a day to 15 minutes.

Steve Graham, a literacy expert at Vanderbilt University, said, "The script that we teach kids today is simple and efficient. Americans are all about efficiency - getting it down without having to think about it."

Graham says that just as computers are a technology, so are pencils and paper.

"So, are pen and pencils still the most practical technology we have?" asked Smith.

"Well, they're clearly the simplest," said Graham. "They're the cheapest. And in many ways, the most portable, 'cause you can take them anywhere. Are they the most effective, is a different question. Kids who write on word processors over time have better quality writing."

"So, if kids just bypassed handwriting altogether and started on keyboards, would they suffer?" asked Smith.

"Probably not," said Graham. "You want to be able to make your text legible, and you want to be able to do it quickly, okay? It also can help you learn new words if you trace them or write them out. But if you're asking, 'Does it help you become a better thinker?' there's no evidence that that's the case."

Others disagree with Graham, citing studies that show that for kids, handwriting is more effective than typing for stimulating memory and language skills.

And with computers still scarce in some classrooms - and keyboards a poor fit for kids' hands - all agree: penmanship counts.

And Graham isn't ready to write off good penmanship yet. He says good handwriting does matter.

"If your text is readable, but hard to read, then people form judgments about the credibility of your ideas, based upon your handwriting," he said.

So, a kid with good handwriting could get better grades? "Yes," he said. "And a kid with poor handwriting gets lower grades on writing assignments."

Does our legibility get better as we get older?

No, said Graham. "What happens is you tend to peak around fourth grade. And as you write more, what happens is, you've got to increase your speed."

Some of us are reminded of that 4th grade peak the hard way. When then-British Prime Minister Gordon Brown wrote a letter of condolence to the mother of a soldier killed in Afghanistan, his sloppy hand and spelling errors so incensed her, she released the letter to the press, causing a penmanship scandal.

And most of us don't give OUR OWN handwriting glowing reviews. A Sunday Morning poll finds that while 8 out of 10 of us write at least some of the time, only 18% call their own handwriting "excellent."

Noted calligrapher Margaret Shepherd has written two books encouraging readers to step away from the mouse, and pen handwritten notes.

Shepherd says you shouldn't be concerned about the quality: "Your handwriting is good enough. It doesn't have to be something from a medieval monastery.

"The worst handwriting, the plainest paper, the generic stamp, all that is still way ahead of the best, trickiest, cutest little e-mail," she said. "They're not even in the same category."

After all, so much of our national history has been written by hand … and our personal history, too.

"Whenever I come across a letter of my mother's, it's like I hear her voice, she's in the room with me," she said.

"And for communications between you and someone you really value, a handwritten letter is just awesome. It's a fabulous storage and display device.

"It's much better than a digital file."

And even these fourth graders, still struggling with how to form those cursive capitals, seem to "get" that handwriting has a place.

When asked why handwriting matters, one girl said, "Well, because you can't just have a computer everywhere you go unless you have, like, a laptop. You can't, like, lug it everywhere."

One boy was more practical: "Maybe sometimes if you're like, maybe if you're like stranded on an island or something, then you'll know how to write."

On a desert island . . . on a job application . . . or for the history books . . . it just may be too soon to sign off on penmanship.

You must be logged in to post comments.

Password (case sensitive):
Remember Me:

Read Comments

Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
  • by scribbler on Jan 24, 2011 at 07:13 AM
    Interesting piece. It's only about letters though. What about numbers?? Calculations require writing, as do measurements, drawings, etc. I know computers can be used for just about everything, but all this talk about "efficiency" and the truth is it's sometimes just a lot faster to jot something down. Handwriting should always be taught!
  • by Pete Zahut on Jan 24, 2011 at 06:16 AM
    Just read some of the comments posted on this web site. Not only can people no longer demonstrate effective penmanship, they can't spell, can't use grammar correctly and can't do simple arithmetic in their heads. The US has become a nation of stupid, narcissistic people - witness the last election and the moronic "debates" over health care (which, BTW, should not be labeled "Obamacare". It should be labeled what it is - the "giving in to Republicans and insurance industry health scam".)
  • by Anonymous on Jan 24, 2011 at 04:44 AM
    Anonymous, Have you ever heard of electronic signatures. I have filed taxes electronically, and for the last 4 or 5 years have never had to actually sign my name anywhere.
  • by Anonymous on Jan 23, 2011 at 04:41 PM
    if you can't write you name, how are you going to sign legal documents?? It usually says sign your name, not print your name.
  • by forwentez Location: la on Jan 23, 2011 at 02:12 PM
    spanish is the best anyway. DUMB AMERICANS
  • by dog Location: gone on Jan 23, 2011 at 01:43 PM
    X . the new signature, Welcome to the illerate 3 rd world country. and yes I can't spell.
  • by VTYSFRWD Location: FLORIDA on Jan 23, 2011 at 12:25 PM
    I enjoy receiving letters and cards written in someone's handwriting. It is a very personal thing and brings one closer to you. I just heard of an 18-year-old, who couldn't write or sign his name. That is just sad. I still write notes to myself in my handwriting, which I notice is getting worse with age. I fear that the lol, brb, gn, and l8er is going to be our next language and I feel we should practice our handwriting as often as possible. When I text, I write the whole word out, just to show myself I can still think and put words together, as well as, practice my typing skills.
  • by david Location: tallahassee on Jan 23, 2011 at 09:26 AM
    High school and college people of today who are graduates are not able to write a complete sentence why wouldn't handwriting be the same with so much computer and smart phone use. Dumbing down of America continues.
WCTV 1801 Halstead Blvd. Tallahassee, FL 32309
Copyright © 2002-2016 - Designed by Gray Digital Media - Powered by Clickability 114448514 -
Gray Television, Inc.